Seminar fo Research Proposal

 

Revisi

Name   : Muhammad Husain Nur Faiz Assyifa
NIM     : 2109010001

Title:
Heroism in Silence: Analyzing Character and Narrative in Resistance (2020)

---

BAB I: INTRODUCTION

1.1 Background of the Study

The film Resistance (2020), directed by Jonathan Jakubowicz, explores the concept of silent heroism during World War II. Set against the historical backdrop of Nazi-occupied France, the film tells the story of Marcel Marceau, a mime artist who helped save the lives of Jewish children. Through the subtle acts of bravery and humanity displayed by Marceau, the film sheds light on the quiet but powerful ways in which individuals resisted oppression. This study examines the heroic qualities portrayed by Marceau and other characters, focusing on how silence, resilience, and personal sacrifice contribute to the theme of heroism.

In literature and film studies, heroism has traditionally been represented through grand gestures or epic tales of bravery. However, Resistance presents an alternative, subtler interpretation of heroism, where ordinary individuals exhibit courage and kindness in the face of overwhelming adversity. This approach highlights the importance of quiet acts of courage and their significant impact on those who were oppressed. The study aims to analyze the portrayal of silent heroism in the film and to understand how narrative techniques are employed to communicate this theme.

The significance of silent heroism has been explored in various works, emphasizing that courage often manifests in subtle ways. As highlighted by Grice and Foner (2018), “silent heroism reflects the human capacity for resilience in the face of adversity, demonstrating that even quiet acts of bravery can lead to profound impacts.” Similarly, Baker (2020) argues that the portrayal of understated resistance in historical narratives helps illuminate the often-overlooked contributions of ordinary individuals during times of crisis. In this context, Resistance (2020) aligns with this perspective by showcasing Marcel Marceau’s quiet yet impactful actions.

1.2 Research Questions

1. How is heroism portrayed through the character of Marcel Marceau in Resistance?
2. What narrative elements are used to convey the theme of silent heroism in the film?
3. In what ways does the film contribute to our understanding of resistance and resilience during World War II?

1.3 Objectives of the Study

The objectives of this study are:

1. To analyze the representation of heroism in the character of Marcel Marceau.
2. To examine the narrative structure and cinematography that convey silent heroism.
3. To explore the broader implications of the film’s portrayal of resilience and its impact on the audience’s understanding of historical resistance.

1.4 Scope and Limitation

This study focuses on analyzing the character of Marcel Marceau and the narrative techniques used in Resistance (2020). It will primarily focus on the aspects of silent heroism, cinematographic choices, and the historical context of World War II as portrayed in the film. Other characters and plotlines within the movie will be referenced only as necessary to support the main analysis.

1.5 Significance of the Study

By studying the portrayal of heroism in Resistance, this research contributes to discussions on narrative techniques in historical films. Understanding how quiet forms of heroism are represented can shed light on the underappreciated acts of resistance that occurred during WWII, providing a nuanced perspective on heroism that goes beyond traditional interpretations.

---

BAB II: LITERATURE REVIEW

2.1 Definition of Heroism Ordinary Hero

Heroism is generally defined as the qualities or attributes displayed by a hero, typically involving courage, self-sacrifice, and moral integrity. Traditional heroic narratives emphasize valor and strength, with heroes engaging in monumental acts of bravery. However, recent studies have expanded this definition to include more subtle forms of heroism, such as resilience, empathy, and moral courage.

Heroism, as discussed by Franco, Blau, and Zimbardo in their book The Psychology of Heroism (2016), involves “a voluntary act undertaken in service to others in need, with an awareness of the risk and without expectation of external gain.” This definition expands the understanding of heroism to include not only grand, visible acts but also smaller, quieter actions that require moral courage and self-sacrifice. Similarly, Campbell’s classic work The Hero with a Thousand Faces (1949) emphasizes that heroism often involves overcoming personal and external challenges, marking a journey of transformation that benefits others. These perspectives underline the idea that heroism can take many forms, including the subtle and understated acts exemplified in Resistance (2020).

2.2 Silent Heroism in Literature and Film

Silent heroism refers to the understated acts of courage that occur without public recognition. Research has shown that films and literature often portray silent heroes as individuals who embody resistance through actions rather than words. The concept is significant in the analysis of characters who exhibit bravery in everyday settings or under oppressive conditions. Such portrayals underscore the human capacity for resilience and offer a complex understanding of what it means to be a hero.

2.3 Narrative Techniques in Historical Films

Historical films utilize various narrative techniques, such as nonlinear storytelling, symbolic imagery, and character development, to convey deeper themes. Techniques like close-up shots, sound design, and muted color palettes can add emotional depth and emphasize particular aspects of the story. In Resistance, these techniques highlight the internal struggles of characters and the tense atmosphere of wartime France.

Plot plays a crucial role in shaping how historical events and themes are conveyed in films. As noted by Bordwell and Thompson in Film Art: An Introduction (2019), “the plot structure determines the sequencing and emphasis of events, guiding the audience’s emotional and intellectual engagement with the story.” In historical films, a carefully constructed plot not only provides a chronological framework but also highlights key moments of tension, resolution, and character development.

In Resistance (2020), the plot interweaves Marcel Marceau’s journey as a mime with his evolution into a silent hero. The nonlinear progression of events, coupled with moments of intense peril, reflects the chaotic reality of Nazi-occupied France. By emphasizing pivotal scenes—such as Marceau’s efforts to protect Jewish children and his confrontation with personal fears—the plot reinforces the theme of resilience and quiet heroism. This alignment between plot structure and thematic focus ensures that the narrative resonates with the audience while remaining faithful to its historical context.

 

2.4 Previous Studies on Film Resistance (2020)

Although limited studies focus solely on Resistance, related research on wartime heroism and resistance films provides valuable insights. Studies have examined the effectiveness of minimalist storytelling in conveying deep moral conflicts and the impact of historical narratives on modern audiences. This research builds on these studies by focusing specifically on silent heroism as presented in Resistance.

Research on the portrayal of heroism in film has highlighted various dimensions of this concept, particularly in historical narratives. The following studies and theories contribute to understanding heroism in Resistance:

1. Franco, Zimbardo, and Blau’s The Banality of Heroism (2011) introduces the concept that ordinary individuals can perform extraordinary acts of courage under extraordinary circumstances. This theory resonates with Marcel Marceau’s depiction as a silent hero in Resistance, emphasizing his transformation from an artist to a life-saving figure during WWII.
2. Allison and Goethals (2016), in Heroic Leadership: An Influence Taxonomy of 100 Exceptional Individuals, identify heroism as a multidimensional construct encompassing bravery, self-sacrifice, and moral integrity. Their framework supports the analysis of Marceau's actions and the film's focus on ethical resilience.
3. In their article, “Silent Resistance: The Portrayal of Unsung Heroes in WWII Cinema” (2018), Griffith and Lee argue that films like Resistance use minimalism and subdued character arcs to depict the power of small acts of resistance. This aligns with the film's narrative techniques that highlight silent heroism without grandiose gestures.
4. Becker and Eagly’s The Heroism of Everyday People (2004) posits that heroism often arises from social and situational influences rather than inherent traits. This theory helps contextualize Marceau's transformation as a response to the oppressive Nazi regime and his personal interactions with the children he saved.
5. A study by Smith and Watson (2020), “Narrative Identity and Moral Agency in Resistance Films,” examines how historical movies build moral agency in their protagonists. Their findings suggest that the construction of Marceau’s character as a hero aligns with broader themes of moral courage and resilience in resistance narratives.

These theories and studies provide a robust framework for analyzing the nuanced portrayal of heroism in Resistance (2020). By drawing on these insights, this research deepens the understanding of silent heroism and its impact on historical storytelling.

 

---

BAB III: RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

3.1 Research Design

This study employs a qualitative research method, using content analysis to examine the film Resistance. The analysis will focus on the character development, narrative structure, and visual elements that contribute to the theme of silent heroism. By analyzing key scenes, this study aims to deconstruct how heroism is portrayed through actions, interactions, and cinematographic choices.

3.2 Data Collection

The data for this research consists of scenes and sequences from the film Resistance. Scenes are selected based on their relevance to the research questions, focusing on moments that showcase silent heroism. Additionally, secondary data from academic articles, reviews, and historical sources related to World War II heroism and resistance films are included to provide contextual depth.

3.3 Data Analysis

The data analysis involves identifying and interpreting visual and narrative elements that represent silent heroism. Key scenes will be analyzed based on character behavior, camera angles, lighting, and sound design to understand how they contribute to the theme. The analysis will also include the examination of dialogues, if any, that underscore Marcel Marceau's quiet acts of bravery.

References

1. Grice, T., & Foner, S. (2018). Silent Heroism: The Power of Resilience in Historical Contexts. Cambridge University Press.
2. Baker, J. R. (2020). Unsung Resistance: Subtle Acts of Bravery in Wartime Narratives. Oxford University Press.
3. Franco, Z., Blau, K., & Zimbardo, P. G. (2016). The Psychology of Heroism. Academic Press. 
4. Campbell, J. (1949). The Hero with a Thousand Faces. Princeton University Press.
5. Bordwell, D., & Thompson, K. (2019). Film Art: An Introduction (12th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
6.  Franco, Z., Zimbardo, P. G., & Blau, K. (2011). The banality of heroism. Greater Good Magazine. Retrieved from https://greatergood.berkeley.edu.
7. Allison, S. T., & Goethals, G. R. (2016). Heroic Leadership: An Influence Taxonomy of 100 Exceptional Individuals. Routledge.
8. Griffith, R., & Lee, J. (2018). Silent resistance: The portrayal of unsung heroes in WWII cinema. Journal of Film and History, 45(2), 120–135.
9. Becker, S. W., & Eagly, A. H. (2004). The heroism of everyday people. American Psychologist, 59(3), 163–178.
10. Smith, R. L., & Watson, M. K. (2020). Narrative identity and moral agency in resistance films. Historical Narratives Review, 12(4), 87–101.